Ironically, I learned that Santa wasn’t real in the temple when I was eleven years old. It was during an adult service. During the sermon, the Rabbi said something like, “You become the tooth fairy/Santa/etc., then your kids become them, and so on.” I looked at my mom, horrified, with tears in my eyes that she had lied to me for all those years. All the cookies we baked for Santa and all the gifts that were left by the fireplace were indeed my mom. Not Santa. I never truly believed that he would visit a little Jewish girl anyway.
Growing Up 100% Jewish
I grew up in a 100% Jewish household. I went to Sunday school and Monday night school so I could become a bat mitzvah. So did my younger brother. But, we still made cookies on Christmas Eve and left them out with a glass of milk for Santa. Santa would leave us some gifts on the fire place. I’ll never forget when Santa left me the No Doubt cassette tape and a cool smiley face backpack–very ’90s!
We also celebrated Hanukkah, lighting the menorah, having family dinner, and opening one present each night. We celebrated the high holidays and I went to a Jewish sleepover camp every summer for eight years. But, I would consider my family to be extremely reformed and not very religious. We just did the bare minimum and never really “drank the kool-aid” and got super involved with our temples or community. I’m not sure why; it just wasn’t our thing.
I Fell in Love With a Catholic Guy
Chrismukkah Was Born!
So, that’s how we adopted Chrismukkah in our house: a mixture of all the best Christmas and Hanukkah traditions in one awesome holiday. (And yes, I’m aware that Seth Cohen on the O.C. created it, so I won’t take credit for it.)
This isn’t groundbreaking stuff here; we haven’t recreated the wheel in any way. Chrismukkah is simple. It’s about honoring the traditions of both holidays. We both knew that it was important to honor the traditions we grew up with and share them with one another. This has become more important as we got married and are now raising a family.
Here’s what Chrismukkah looks like for us:
We have a tree.
It’s funny because this is something I have yet to nail in my many years of celebrating. A few years ago at the store, I called my husband numerous times while trying to pick out ornaments for our tree. It was humorous; I was lost yet again. I always end up buying not enough ornaments, forgetting a tree skirt, or missing another key detail. But the spirit of Chrismukkah is still there and that’s all that matters.
We have a Menorah.
Do we light it every night? I’d be lying if I said yes. But, I love how beautiful it looks on our fireplace mantle. As our son and daughter grow up, I envision us doing the candles every night for eight nights. I will give my husband credit; he knows the candle prayer in Hebrew and it’s super cute.
We have a Hanukkah party.
This is with my family. For our family, every Jewish holiday consists of the same menu: turkey, brisket, matzo ball soup, challah bread, and mashed potatoes. Of course, Hanukkah would not be complete without potato latkes with applesauce or sour cream on top. If you’ve never tried these, I highly, highly recommend them!
We celebrate Christmas Eve and Christmas Day.
This is with my husband’s family. I look forward to it every year. Although I still haven’t gotten brave enough to eat the ham, I love Christmas Eve. My husband’s family has someone dress up like Santa and surprise all the little kids. Then we all read The Night Before Christmas by the fire. Oh, and I discovered cherry chip cake one Christmas Eve, and it’s the best cake ever.
On Christmas Day, we go to my step-dad’s family party. We eat appetizers, drink the family punch, and play games. It’s another nice tradition to add to Chrismukkah.
We order Chinese food.
We do this on Christmas Day for dinner. The past couple of years it hasn’t worked out so well because the restaurant has been so busy, they lost our order. Pro-tip: order early in the day and reheat it. We wouldn’t be a half-Jewish family if we didn’t have Chinese food during Christmas.
We sing songs.
What’s Important About Chrismukkah
Do we have eight crazy nights? Well . . . not exactly. As our kids grow, we’ll definitely do one small present each night like I did as a kid. But just to make things simple right now, we open gifts on Christmas Day.
The holidays are a very important time for me. Not because of the gifts–I think gifts are fun and nice, but they can add a lot of stress to the season. As my family grows and I learn more life lessons, I realize the holiday time is about time with the family and friends I love the most.
Taking time to slow down. To show love, gratitude, and appreciation for one another. To embrace the passed-down holiday traditions and create our own as a family. Although we’re far from religious, we believe in this time of year. The magic is there–if you’re open to seeing it.